Invalid Reasons For Why A Character Should Not Be Redeemed:

Let's talk about this little scene.

They're looking for Shadow, and Knuckles notices that the GUN truck is falling toward them. He shoves his brothers out of the way, and catches the truck, neat as you please.

He could have grabbed them and pulled them away, making sure they were safe when the truck landed. He could have punched the falling vehicle, shattering it to bits and causing all sorts of rubble and debris.

But he didn't. He pushed his brothers behind him, and caught the truck.

He showed off his strength, following it up with hefting it on one hand, and boasting once again about being "one million percent muscle".

Knuckles may have settled into family life, may have found a new tribe, but he's still a warrior, and is proud of his strength. He's proud of the abilities he has, and I think sometimes feels like they're not appreciated enough, as they're for fighting and after the last movie, he and the other boys have seemingly settled into a nice, quiet, non-violent family life.

Tails likely has been instrumental in fixing or improving various things about the house or town, and Sonic is the first child so he's already found his comfy spot in the family and community.

But what about Knuckles? His strength likely isn't as big a benefit in daily life. May be a bit of a hinderance, if he doesn't pay attention and control it properly. So he may have been hearing "Watch your strength, Knux," or "Not all conflicts require violence to solve, Knux," which is so different from what he's used to.

While he doesn't always immediately jump to violence to solve all his problems, that's his strength, no pun intended. In his journeys through the galaxy, he had to fight to survive. Fight to keep himself safe. And even in circumstances where he didn't want to fight, he was usually forced into it. So this is his norm.

So I feel like he caught that falling truck not only to save his brothers, but to remind them what he's capable of. It was kind of a "Look, I am your brother, I am happy in my new tribe, but I am still someone to be respected because of my abilities."

It could have also been a lowkey show of how he would protect them. Anyone could pull someone to safety, but only he could catch a falling multi-ton vehicle as though it were nothing more than a tossed baseball.

But now it's discouraged. Maybe he feels he's getting weak. Getting soft because he's not being forced to fight on a regular basis. Which is I think why he so willingly rushed to fight Shadow when it seemed like talking wasn't working.

In the novelization of the movie, after Shadow kicks his butt, when the others ask if he's okay he tells them that he "might be a bit rusty". His pride is what took the real beating, and may have added to this feeling of his strength being dismissed. Of him losing what made him special.

This is further enforced by being essentially benched during the raid on the GUN HQ. His greatest asset is his strength, but it's not being utilized except "in case of emergency". Which, based on how the others behaved, they didn't think it would be necessary. So they essentially told him he was the failsafe, the backup, even though they--and likely HE--did not expect to need him.

His constant boasts about how easily he could break the glass may have been as much for his own morale as convincing the others he would be there if necessary. He is a formidable warrior, he has bested many a foe in his years. He is still a force to be reckoned with, even if he hadn't been challenged much in the months since the last battle with Robotnik.

He needs to feel useful. To feel important to the rest of his tribe. And maybe he's felt that the others kind of forgot just how impressive he is in his own right.

His adventures during the series showed him how it was okay to let his guard down and not be so serious all the time. And we see that in the film. We see him content with simply being a member of the family, we see him goofing off with his brothers. Even while they went over the plan, he sat with his little hat and munched on some bread.

(The grumpy face is undone by the beanie, sweetheart.)

Knuckles does best when facing threats head on. He prefers to run in and deal with the problem up front, and get on with his life. Stealth and plans and even working with other people is new to him. But he trusts his brother, he trusts his tribe, and he will stay off to the side until he's needed. (Maybe even moreso now that he saw that rushing in to fight Shadow didn't get him anywhere.)

But when he's needed, he will show them that his strength is just as much an asset as Tails' brains and Sonic's speed. Even if it had unexpected consequences.

Knuckles has a much bigger adjustment to Earth and family life than either of the other two boys. Because his life up to that point was fighting, keeping on the move and ahead of bounty hunters, and searching for the one thing that meant more to his people than any other. He had a huge weight on his shoulders, one that neither Sonic nor Tails could understand. Even the humans in his life couldn't possibly comprehend just how important it was for him to find the Master Emerald and allow his entire species to rest in peace once more.

But now that his quest was done, and he doesn't have to look over his shoulder as much as he used to, he likely struggles with how he fits in with the world. For the longest time he was The Most Dangerous Warrior in the Galaxy, and the Last of the Echidna. Now he's simply Knuckles. And he may be having a hard time finding what that actually means, to him and to those he loves.

~~~

Check out my other Sonic 3 analysis posts

And then Donnie never makes a joke ever again

I suppose it's handy that the day I finally got around to making a Tumblr account was also the day I'd planned on updating a fic, so may as well put it here as well for my first post!!! :D Chapter summary:

Paper apparently beats rock.

And APPARENTLY the twins actually have a mother. There are conflicting feelings about that. Series link for those of you who are new to this, because this chapter is smack dab in the middle of all the action XD : https://archiveofourown.org/series/2959497

Fun fact: back in their younger days. Ray and Wu were best friends.

I find it quite wholesome that the friendship extended to the next generation

Kai (Ninjago)

Leo (Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles)

Tigress (Kung Fu Panda)

Elena (Elena of Avalor)

Zuko (Avatar: the Last Airbender)

Sonic (Sonic Live-action Movies)

Hermione (Harry Potter)

Sofia (Sofia the First)

Lucky (Spirit: Riding Free)

Hiro (Big Hero 6)

And I think all my mutuals have already been tagged- 😂

(ran out of room and had to pick and choose which fandoms to use 😭)

restarting the post chain bc it was getting long

10 fandoms, 10 characters

in which you list 10 of your favorite characters from 10 different fandoms and tag your mutuals

here are mine, in no particular order:

Donnie (Rise of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles)

Adrian Monk (Monk)

Nimona (Nimona, both the graphic novel and the movie)

Scratch (Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog)

Murderbot (The Murderbot Diaries)

Mina Harker (Dracula)

Dick Grayson (DC)

Bunny (90s Sonic the Hedgehog. different show, so im counting it as a different fandom)

Julie Crews (The Dead Take the A Train)

Dulcinea (Adventures of Puss in Boots)

ty @fandomfive39 for the tag!

no pressure tagging @beanb-urrito, @markwest98, @red-hood-redemption, @boxonarock, @scattered-winter, @sunhaloscarab, @yellowhollyhock, @waturmomscreamsinbed, and anyone else who wants to hop on! (also, lmk if you dont wanna be tagged in these <3)

@alcadanon, @fancytomato, @inkyrainstorms, @raphala-389

Tagged by the wonderful @theresa-of-liechtenstein I'm so so sorries I forgor

Tagging @strollingsquid @discordant-daydreams @iamthesub-librarian @kingscythe @crossnamara

consider: teenagers aren’t apathetic about everything they’re just used to you shitting all over whatever they show excitement about

Monster:

*POV: Casey Jr is fighting a monster*

Future Leo: Just stay calm! You already have everything you need to beat it!

Casey Jr: The power to believe in myself!?

Future Leo: NO, A CHAINSAW HOCKEY STICK! KILL IT!!

Demonstrating the rope dart (繩標; sheng2biao1)

[eng by me]