One Thing That Kinda Frustrates Me About Shen Jiu Fics Is That They So Often Try To Sanitize Him. Make

One thing that kinda frustrates me about Shen Jiu fics is that they so often try to sanitize him. Make him nicer/more misunderstood than he actually is.

Like, he was definitely very misunderstood in source material, but he also was straight up a terrible person too, y'know? Both things can be true at once.

The biggest thing is his treatment of Luo Binghe, playing on the idea that it wasn't *as* bad as the characters thought it was. Now, this is just plain wrong cause we know from the extras that SJ gave Binghe the fake cultivation manual with the intent that it would literally explode him. He really wanted to murder that kid, yall. Loony toonz ass villain. Keep this man away from children

And he was definitely a total asshole to all his coworkers, even during disciple days. The other Peak Lords are under no expectation to like him nor tolerate his behavior, especially since they (except Yue Qingyuan) don't know about his backstory (very intentional on SJs part)! SJ very deliberately ostracized himself. His nasty reputation didn't just spring up out of nowhere. He has agency even in other people's opinions of him.

This is particularly notable in his interactions with Liu Qingge. It wasn't "LQG bullies poor SJ and spreads nasty rumors about him." It was a rivalry, a give and take between the both of them. They were both assholes to each other, but clearly, despite the animosity, there was some deeper feeling (SJ being so affected after LQG's murder accusations and then later death). Again, agency is key here.

He's also completely unrepentant until the very end! He will never apologize ever, so no sudden "oh god, what have I done?" heel-turns for him, buddy. If it was that easy, then he wouldn't have gotten human sticked in the first place.

SJ is tragic and sympathetic. SJ is also an awful person and a complete asshole. He's allowed to be both, and both of these sides of him are what makes him an interesting and engaging character.

Edit: holy shit stop interacting with this post everytime I open my notifications I think I’m getting reactions to my more recent shit and instead it’s just this bs. Anyways thanks for 1k notes

More Posts from Erionella and Others

2 weeks ago
MXTX Cookie Run AU (SVSSS) Doodle Dumps
MXTX Cookie Run AU (SVSSS) Doodle Dumps
MXTX Cookie Run AU (SVSSS) Doodle Dumps
MXTX Cookie Run AU (SVSSS) Doodle Dumps
MXTX Cookie Run AU (SVSSS) Doodle Dumps
MXTX Cookie Run AU (SVSSS) Doodle Dumps
MXTX Cookie Run AU (SVSSS) Doodle Dumps

MXTX Cookie Run AU (SVSSS) doodle dumps

Some lore mixed in from CRK and CRWC!

2 months ago

tbh i dunno why so many sj apologists are anti-yqy. because like????? he is your mascot. he was the originator. the head honcho of excusing sj's levels of unmitigated villainy. look into my eyes and tell me that qi ge wouldn't blush and kick his feet if he saw xiao jiu commit murder. actually we don't NEED to imagine bc jiumei did just that and yue qi just grabbed his hand and ran, no thoughts head empty. arson? child abuse?? yue qi doesn't care. whatever makes xiao jiu happy <3

3 weeks ago

*Sherlock and William are dating*

Mycroft: What did you two do last night?

Sherlock: Examined a murder scene.

Mycroft: You're supposed to be dating, not detecting!

Sherlock: We are. It's a detective date.

1 month ago
I Was Thinking About An AU Where SY And SJ Met Each Other Through The Qiu Manor And Instead Of SJ Studying

I was thinking about an AU where SY and SJ met each other through the Qiu manor and instead of SJ studying under the demonic cultivator he escapes with SY. SY and SJ struggle and finally get to Cang Qiong where SJ gets into Qing Jing and SJ goes to the Beast peak [not very imaginative i know :') ]. They both move through the ranks and reach peak lord status. I like to think its a slow burn and they both end up falling in love. SY and SJ both helping each other heal. I'm not a good writer sorry I just really love the idea of SY/SJ. And I also wanted to practice on my two favorite brushes.

7 months ago
The Lord Is Testing Me.

The Lord is testing me.

LMFAOOOO I’M CRYING

The Lord Is Testing Me.
3 weeks ago

men have one homoerotic rivalry and make it everyones problem for the rest of their life

4 months ago

"All those empty rooms

We could have been anywhere, anywhere else

Instead, I made a bed with apathy

My heart knew the weight

Ten years worth of dust and neglect

We made our peace with weariness and let it be..."

(Song: The Moon will Sing by the Crane Wives)

7 months ago

on the yqy gets truth serumed thing: we find out because during a peak lord meeting, lqg says smth smth sqq sux and i hate him, and usually what gets said is "shidi is permitted to his own opinion, of course, but blablabla-" what comes out the sect leaders mouth THIS time, however, is "oh fuck your mother you foul tempered brat; jiu can do as he pleases and so help me if he threatens to leave because of this i will use your skin as a rug ^^" no one was ready.

YES

Exactly this is the vibe I picture if Yue Qingyuan got dosed with a truth serum.

Someone says something about how Shen Qingqiu's whoring is dragging the sect's reputation down, but what could they really expect from a man like that. Complete with a meaningful glance. And of course it's expected that Yue Qingyuan will take his side, even if he tries to word it diplomatically, they all know how he is...

And then Yue Qingyuan says "I'm going to break your jaw and rip out your lying tongue for slandering Shen Jiu. We don't even have anything in the rules forbidding sex you stupid piece of-" at which point Liu Qingge and Mu Qingfang both tackle him because something is clearly wrong with him and they can't rule out possession right away.

Everybody is mortified when Mu Qingfang confirms it's a truth pollen, but Shen Qingqiu just sits there completely floored because Yue Qingyuan would commit violence for him? Despite everything?? Then why hasn't he done any of that?! At least put in a little more effort when standing up for him to discourage the rich idiots from picking on him! Useless shixiong.

They wrap Yue Qingyuan in immortal binding cables because they don't trust his word that he always thinks like this and the risk of him acting on it is not one the can take, and he kneels in front of Shen Qingqiu and tells him that he would do anything to have his trust, his love back. If Shen Jiu asks him to rip out his useless, treacherous tongue, to crack open his chest and hand him his still beating heart as proof of his love, he would do so even if it's the last thing he would do in this life.

And Shen Qingqiu swoons because okay, there's something fishy here, but that's the kind of devotion he wants (devotion to match his own) and he is still fucking mad, don't get him wrong, but keep talking he's listening.


Tags
1 month ago

AU/fic prompt where Shen Yuan does not pull off the ruse at all. All the peak lords look at him like 'no, nowhere enough contempt in that look that ain't Shen Jiu' but no one calls because while observing trying figure out possession they see his knowledge of things not just Shen Jiu BUT no one else should know like you are casually talking about a creature that for all we know has been extinct for millennia and casually mentioning about things going on no ones told.

All of collectively decide he's a god. (Apart from Shang Qinghua who hasn't noticed all this because he is doing ALL THE PAPERWORK while the other peak lords are in front of their WTF conspiracy board. He doesn't know what they're doing he doesn't care he just wants a nap.)

Just all peak lords sure Shen Jiu died and now there's a god in his body.

Luo Binghe of course hearing they're mutters and instantly being like 'yep makes perfect sense Shizun is perfect' and then turning to Meng Mo and being like 'how to I court a god?'

After Shang Qinghua and Shen Yuan meet other peak lords looking and listening in on them talking in ANOTHER LANGUAGE THEY HAVE NEVER HEARD AND NO RECORD OF and saying things that make no sense and are like 'both gods, that little shit was a god this whole time...I MADE A GOD THE BUDGETING?

Meanwhile Luo Binghe trying become demonic emperor and gain all the power like 'ok if I take over the entire world I think i should be able to start courting Shizun... maybe all 3 first? when I can start sending courting gifts to a god?'

Bonus Mobei Jun caught on right away there was something up with Shang Qinghua and quickly decided god and has an entire council of demons trying to figure out how to court a god... they have no basis for this. Can you bride nap a god? is that allowed? what courting gifts would even work? Mobei Jun has been beating him up because the council couldn't stop him doing something but since he hasn't been responding figure they need something else.

Just Shen Yuan and Shang Qinghua convinced they have fooled everyone just like 'don't be suspicious' while everyone else is like 'We've connected the dots... they're gods'

6 months ago
Close Enough, Welcome Back Bingqiu
Close Enough, Welcome Back Bingqiu

Close enough, welcome back Bingqiu


Tags
  • renacuajo16
    renacuajo16 liked this · 5 days ago
  • lesbianfreakazoid
    lesbianfreakazoid liked this · 6 days ago
  • stephgina
    stephgina liked this · 6 days ago
  • darkthoughts18
    darkthoughts18 reblogged this · 6 days ago
  • darkthoughts18
    darkthoughts18 liked this · 6 days ago
  • clearcycledonut
    clearcycledonut liked this · 1 week ago
  • bloomyblemy
    bloomyblemy reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • bloomyblemy
    bloomyblemy liked this · 1 week ago
  • fluffyplushiez
    fluffyplushiez liked this · 1 week ago
  • theveggster
    theveggster liked this · 1 week ago
  • alltimeshipper
    alltimeshipper liked this · 1 week ago
  • bookbananacup
    bookbananacup liked this · 1 week ago
  • noonthemoon
    noonthemoon reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • noonthemoon
    noonthemoon liked this · 1 week ago
  • kirbyvacuum
    kirbyvacuum liked this · 1 week ago
  • dream-about-dancing
    dream-about-dancing liked this · 1 week ago
  • sunnyturnip
    sunnyturnip liked this · 1 week ago
  • soundofsavorypurpose
    soundofsavorypurpose liked this · 1 week ago
  • bluejeanswarmsweater
    bluejeanswarmsweater liked this · 1 week ago
  • funkyfridayflowers
    funkyfridayflowers liked this · 1 week ago
  • zamgxve
    zamgxve liked this · 1 week ago
  • tinatisms
    tinatisms liked this · 1 week ago
  • rehtae-noia
    rehtae-noia liked this · 1 week ago
  • criticaloverthinker
    criticaloverthinker reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • viv-ennjzz
    viv-ennjzz liked this · 1 week ago
  • silva214
    silva214 liked this · 1 week ago
  • psycho-parkway
    psycho-parkway reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • psycho-parkway
    psycho-parkway liked this · 1 week ago
  • hcffukmhddddx
    hcffukmhddddx liked this · 1 week ago
  • meixue-nim
    meixue-nim liked this · 1 week ago
  • stadesmartly
    stadesmartly liked this · 1 week ago
  • scrumptiousenemyblaze
    scrumptiousenemyblaze liked this · 2 weeks ago
  • apple-orchard-disco
    apple-orchard-disco liked this · 2 weeks ago
  • doggamn-it
    doggamn-it reblogged this · 2 weeks ago
  • confidentialartist
    confidentialartist liked this · 2 weeks ago
  • peppermintprince-broccolichild
    peppermintprince-broccolichild liked this · 2 weeks ago
  • yur-luy
    yur-luy liked this · 2 weeks ago
  • wrenmalin08
    wrenmalin08 liked this · 2 weeks ago
  • yukki0n0
    yukki0n0 liked this · 2 weeks ago
  • supernova--light
    supernova--light liked this · 2 weeks ago
  • atomictacomaker
    atomictacomaker liked this · 2 weeks ago
  • pepe-da-phrog
    pepe-da-phrog liked this · 2 weeks ago
  • olympian-mystery
    olympian-mystery liked this · 2 weeks ago
  • curious-magpie
    curious-magpie liked this · 2 weeks ago
  • shroudedshadows
    shroudedshadows liked this · 2 weeks ago
erionella - Nella
Nella

[|🍉| scrawling around tumblr, does nothing to help the community]Shen Jiu defender and apologist, also a 79 enthusiastMultishipper and Multifandom, just awfully invested in svsss rn

176 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags